31 January 2014 | bybob the moo(United Kingdom) See all my reviews
I’ve not seen the new Spike Jonse film Her but watching this episode of Black Mirror which was screened over a year before Her was released in the US does rather make one think that Charlie Brooker would have some reason to be aggrieved at a film doing so well with a similar idea at its core. In the case of Be Right Back the plot sees Martha and Ash as a couple with Ash being a heavy online presence via social networks and so on. When Ash dies leaving Martha alone she turns to a piece of software which will emulate your former partner and they begin chatting online.Although I did not think the first season of Back Mirror was perfect I really did like that it is able to take current situations and move them a few steps down a logical or reasonable line and then see what happens in a specific situation. As with the previous season this episode very much sticks with technology as its jumping off point but it is most in common with the third episode of the first season it the way it is driven by an emotional core. The idea in this case is that just as it is possible already to have software that can just about text you like a person so in theory it should be possible to have software that builds a you based on all your emails texts Facebook posts and so on; OK it is a few steps beyond Amazon suggesting products based on your purchasing history but it is effective because it doesn’t seem too far away and thus we are not given the comfort of a future far from our own.With small steps we get to a plot that is far-fetched while being conceivable and with this idea as the narrative device Brooker builds a story that is emotionally engaging as we can both empathize with what Martha does while also seeing how bad a thing it is in the grand scheme of things just like it being easy to see the faults of others from a distance while totally failing to see the same in ourselves. It is really moving and the conflict is throughout the story which means that it never stops working on the level it does at the start. The downside is that it ends in the same mould rather than having something dramatic but still it is effective for what it does.The direction is good and the tone matches Brooker’s excellent writing. If I didn’t already know this is the same sarcastic and miserable Brooker we see on Screen wipe I never would have believed he wrote this. What really seals the deal though is the performance from Atwell because she is amazing. She really understands her character and she convinces through the story whether she be content grieving denying hurting or accepting. The story is essentially a two-harden but she is the lion’s share of it and her success is the film’s success. Gleeson is more of a device than character but his performance is also well pitched convincing in how he needs to be even if Atwell gets the better of the split.This film will be hard to watch in the wake of Her since thematically they are similar but I’m sure this is just coincidence. It is best to ignore this and focus on the film doing what it does because it is clever engaging convincing moving and sobering. Hard to believe that the guy cursing at his TV would turn out to be such a good sci-fi writer or that the pretty girl from the Captain America film would have such a great performance in her but BRB is great.
Description:Acomparativefilm analysis is not a review or summary of the plot it should go deeper into analysis and reaction. It should discuss the issues raised by the films address the filmsimportance and purpose state reactions to the content and quality of the films and connect it to ideas and material presented in class. It should be a minimum ofthree fullpages(not including your Works Cited page)and include the following (in any order you choose).
Suggestion:Use a hook (an opening paragraph that catches your readers attention). For example:
Describe a scene incident or bit of dialogue from the films
connect the movie to something happening in society today
Movie Analysis/ComparisonGrading Sheet
An A paper will: